I hear the broadway musical adaptation of this book is phenomenal. In fact, I hear it is coming to Boise for more than two weeks. I hear that it may sell out most evenings. Local radio stations are giving away VIP packages and such.
I have to wonder ............
Actually, I am curious as to how they managed to adapt this book to broadway.
As most people know, it is the story of Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West, before she became such. That part of the story was really great. The tales during her childhood and school days were great. They gave the Witch such depth and the fact that she was born green gave her enough tragedy to deal with. What I had a hard time grasping was the political concepts throughout the book. Not that I don't grasp politics, but mostly I read to be entertained and it took me forever to get through this book because at most points I was thinking to myself, "So what?"
There were lots of religious points to the book, too. I could dig that. McGuire did a great job of creating religious aspects that never really got fully explained. OR perhaps I had fallen asleep through those parts. I guess all of the elements combined were intended to give a super sense of depth to an otherwise green character.
I have never read the original book "Wizard of Oz" so perhaps I am missing some key elements here, but there were many points during this novel that I thought they skewed many of the characters out of the realm of what they should have been.
I believe that this book could have been more entertaining than it was. Perhaps the Broadway Musical is more so. I'm not counting on it, though. I suppose I should make a point to go see it, so that I can write a review of that, too.
There was a lot of NO closure with many of the characters, and other times the author jumps around. Actually, he jumped around A LOT. Very irritating.
This is a book that I will never read again. It had come HIGHLY recommended from many friends, and I have to wonder why. Why was this book so recommended? Perhaps it was not to my liking because I am way more into fantasy books that don't take as long to read. (Don't judge!)
I will more than likely try to pick up a copy of the original Wizard of Oz to see if I am misjudging this story or not. I will at least give it that chance and adjust my thoughts accordingly.
Until then, I'll wait for the DVD release of Wicked.
Rating:
Upon further searching the internet for one who thinks as I do, I did find a 1 star review of Wicked, but the reviewer has this to say about the musical:
"SEE THE SHOW: The broadway show is wonderful and amazing. It is everything that this book is not. However, don't go thinking that they have much in common, because they don't. The plot in the show makes sense, is interesting (far more interesting than the plot in the book), creates characters with whom you really become involved AND gives you a GREAT payoff in the end, explaining things in a MUCH better way and giving you a WONDERFUL and different point of view of the whole story of Oz. The show is one of the best that I have ever seen, and I have seen quite a few. Don't miss Julie Murney as Elphaba, if you get a chance.
THE SHOW: 2 THUMBS UP, 4 STARS, DON'T MISS IT!
THE BOOK: 2 thumbs down, 0 stars, skip it."
Perhaps I will take that very good advice.....